Roger D. Jones
English 3321, Short Story
Fall 1997
Short Story Closure
Closure is the term that refers to the endings of literary works. The purpose of the ending of a story is to resolve all of the conflicts within the story, to create a sense of resolution or stability in the mind of the reader, and/or to complete the sense of circularity or overall aesthetic oneness and unity that characterizes a work of literature. In his book Toward an Ending: Closure and Structure in the American Short Story, critic John Gerlach identifies the following methods by which story writers end their stories:
- Solution to a Central Problem
- Natural Termination
- Completion of Antithesis
- Manifestation of a Moral
- Encapsulation
These are broken down as follows:
I. Solution to a Central Problem:
- a character faces a problem or desires to reach a goal; story ends with this occurring in one way or another
II. Natural Termination: i.e. the story ends with a natural occurrence or process
Modes:
a. death
b. sleep
c. visit and return
d. bliss, satisfaction, euphoria
III. Completion of Antithesis: the completion or circularity of a subject
- "The mental equivalent of a character setting out on an adventure is a character exploring a range of attitudes toward a subject"
a. circularity
b. move from one pole to another (love to hate, etc.)
- "Before we can sense that something is closed, we must be able to judge its boundaries, to feel that it will not move further in time and space."
- "Antithesis [of all closural devices] is the most firmly anchored not just in narrative, but in the act of perception."
IV. Manifestation of a Moral:
- "the short story has many sources, one of which is the parable or exemplum: that is, tales that were very brief, were once offered as illustrations of the ideas that cultures once regarded as necessary for survival."
- "the moral has become the theme or character's (or reader's) self-realization"
V. Encapsulation: "a coda that distances the reader from the story by altering thepoint of view or summarizing the passing of time"
- this was a common mode of closure in the 19th-century
- "Endings are in one sense in the reader's head: the reader feels them, creates them."
- "These various types or levels of closure rarely operate in isolation."
BACK